What a Tax Attorney Does That Your CPA Doesn’t
Let me say the important part first: a good CPA is one of the most valuable advisors you can have, and many CPAs are my colleagues, referral partners, and clients. This is not about who is better. The two roles overlap, and the best outcomes usually come from a CPA and a tax attorney working together. But they are different jobs — and knowing the difference tells you when you need each.
Where the roles overlap
Both plan for taxes. A sophisticated CPA does far more than file returns — accounting, reporting, and genuine tax planning. On the planning side, a good CPA and a tax attorney can look a great deal alike, and often reach the same place.
Where a tax attorney is doing something different
- Legal interpretation and structuring. Applying the law to your specific facts, structuring a transaction or an entity so it holds up, and drafting the binding legal documents that make it real — that is legal work.
- Representation in disputes. When a position is challenged — an audit heading toward appeals, a dispute with the IRS or the Illinois Department of Revenue, or litigation — an attorney represents you and argues the law.
- Privilege. The protection most people underestimate until they need it.
The privilege difference, in plain terms
Your communications with your attorney for legal advice are protected by attorney-client privilege — broadly, in civil and criminal matters alike. Communications with a CPA have only a narrow federal protection, the “tax practitioner privilege” under IRC § 7525. That privilege is civil-only. It does not apply in criminal matters, does not cover return preparation, does not extend to tax-shelter advice, and does not apply in state proceedings.
Why it matters: if a tax issue could ever turn criminal — unreported income, an aggressive position, a sensitive audit — the protection around your CPA communications can evaporate at exactly the wrong moment. Attorney-client privilege does not. There is even a tool for bridging the two: in a Kovel arrangement, an attorney engages the accountant, extending privilege to that work — but it only works when it is set up in advance, through counsel.
When to bring in a tax attorney
- You are structuring a transaction, forming or reorganizing an entity, or doing anything where how it is documented determines the tax.
- You are facing an audit, an appeal, or a dispute — especially one with any criminal exposure.
- You want a position or a plan built to be defended if it is second-guessed.
- You have a matter where confidentiality and privilege genuinely matter.
Have a situation this touches?
A first conversation is free, and I’ll tell you plainly whether this applies to you and where the value is.
Schedule a consultation →